Dear Diet, I am Sorry.

Please apologize to your diets because this recipe is going to ruin them. This is quite possibly the tastiest pie ever. I am huge peanut butter lover for dessert, with peanut butter pie being top on my list of favorite desserts. I knew when I saw this recipe it was love at first site. Oreos for the crust and crushed Reeses Cups inside- can a dessert really get any better? Not only is this pie delish but it is so easy to make. No baking except a few minutes for the crust. You just pop it in the freezer and enjoy a few hours later. I polished off my piece and the hubby’s this weekend and have been enjoying the leftovers everyday. You’re welcome, this recipe rocks.

Frozen Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie

Makes one 9 inch pie or three 4 inch mini pies.

Preparation: Lightly butter springform pan if it is not non-stick. If you do not have a springform pan line a cake pan with a piece of lightly buttered foil leaving a one inch over hang around the edges for easy pie removal or alternately use a traditional pie pan.

•24 oreo cookies, crushed
•4 tablespoon unsalted butter, melted
•2 ½ cups Cool Whip
•¾ cup creamy peanut butter
•½ cup confectioner sugar
•½ cup crushed Reeses Peanut Butter Cups

Oreo Crust Instructions:
1.Place Oreos in a food processor or blender and pulse until cookies are finely crumbed. Alternatively, place Oreos in a plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin. Mix in the melted butter and then firmly press crumbs into pan to create a crust. Bake crust at 350 degrees F for 7-10 minutes.

Reese Peanut Butter Pie Filling Instructions:
1.Place peanut butter and confectioner sugar in a pan over low heat and stir until combined and peanut butter is melted. Set aside for five minutes to cool. Gently fold in peanut butter mixture into Cool Whip until combined. Gently fold in crushed Reese’s pieces into peanut butter Cool Whip mixture.
2.Pour mixture into Oreo crust and freeze for 3 hours. Garnish with caramel and chocolate drizzle (for added decadence rim with chopped Reese’s pieces).

** I made one pie in a springform pan but really think any pie pan would work. I also added more cool whip than the recipe called for to make the filling fluffier. The photo is not mine, the pie was already half eaten when I realized I forgot to take a picture of ours. That is how good it is, no time to even think about photos.**

photo via
You can check out the original recipe HERE


  1. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 12:05 pm

    oh. my.god. that sounds AMAZING…going in my pile of recipes to try. Thanks!

  2. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 12:16 pm

    I'm making this for my hubby's bday later this month! pinned! THANK YOU! 🙂

  3. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 12:51 pm

    That's fabulous girl 🙂 I'm def going to try and make that!

  4. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 12:54 pm

    Wow wow wow! Another reason I need to buy a springform pan.

  5. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 12:56 pm

    OMG i just got back from vacation, I cannot go around eating this fabulous pie!! This looks amazing….guess I will run an extra mile today!

  6. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 1:07 pm

    That looks to die for!!! I love all of your recipes! Do you have them stored in a place on your blog to look up some old ones you posted?

  7. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 1:15 pm

    Dear Natalie, my ass is sorry.

    I am trying this recipe out this weekend when we get back to Richmond. It's insane.

  8. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 1:46 pm

    oh my yumminess!!! looks delish! thanks natalie for posting! i am trying to lose the baby weight! 🙂 i just may have to try this!

  9. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 2:15 pm

    Shut the door!! That looks amazing and I have a weakness for anything with Reeses Cups. I HAVE to make this.

  10. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 2:33 pm

    I think I'm going to attempt individual pies for a party this weekend!

  11. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 3:13 pm

    YUMMMMMMMMMM!!!! I am so in love with this! So decadent and delicious looking!

  12. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 3:17 pm

    that sounds amazing!! anything with an oreo cookie crust and pb cups is automatically delish. cant wait to try it.

  13. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 4:53 pm

    you're killing me! we only have a few pieces of the blueberry banana bread left, and I'm already itching to make something else!

  14. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 5:35 pm

    This is going in my belly. ASAP. You are definitely ruining any chance at a diet that I might have had…if I wasn't too lazy/uninclined to start one in the first place! YUM.

  15. Avatar August 3, 2011 / 7:01 pm

    oh my yum. making immediately. diet can wait.

  16. Avatar August 4, 2011 / 6:27 pm

    Yowza. So amazing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *